Almost every small business in the Chicagoland area faces this decision at some point: Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace? Sometimes it comes up when you're starting fresh and need to set up business email. Sometimes it comes up when a team is frustrated with their current setup and wants to switch. Sometimes it comes up when a business gets acquired or merges with another company and suddenly has people on both platforms trying to collaborate.
Both products are mature, capable, and widely used. Both will handle your email, documents, file storage, video calls, and team communication. Neither is dramatically better than the other in an absolute sense. But they're built with different assumptions about how people work, and for a given business at a given stage, one is almost always the smarter choice.
This post gives you a practical framework for making that call, without the marketing language from either vendor.
What You're Choosing Between
Microsoft 365 (formerly Office 365) is built around desktop applications. Word, Excel, PowerPoint and Outlook are the core. The cloud layer (OneDrive, SharePoint, Teams) was added on top of a decades-old desktop software foundation, and it shows. Microsoft 365 is powerful, deeply integrated with Windows, and extremely capable for complex documents and spreadsheets. It's also more complex to administer and has a steeper learning curve for users who aren't already familiar with the Microsoft ecosystem.
Google Workspace (formerly G Suite) is built browser-first. Gmail, Google Docs, Sheets, Drive, and Meet were designed to run in a tab, not as installed software. Real-time collaboration (multiple people editing the same document at once without file conflicts) is native to the platform rather than bolted on. Administration is significantly simpler, and the learning curve is lower for users who spend most of their day in a browser. The tradeoff is that Google's apps are less powerful for complex formatting, advanced spreadsheet work, and document-heavy workflows.
The choice usually comes down to which platform fits how your team works.
Plans: Compare Tiers, Then Check Current Prices
Both platforms sell three business tiers, and the tiers line up closely. Both vendors change prices and promotions often (Google, for example, shows a discount for a one-year commitment), so check current pricing on each vendor's site for your seat count and billing term rather than relying on figures in an article.
| Tier | Microsoft 365 | Google Workspace |
|---|---|---|
| Entry | Business Basic: web and mobile apps, 50 GB mailbox, 1 TB OneDrive per user, Teams meetings for up to 300 people | Business Starter: 30 GB pooled storage per user, Meet calls for up to 100 people |
| Middle | Business Standard: adds desktop Word, Excel, PowerPoint and Outlook on up to five PCs or Macs, five tablets and five phones per user | Business Standard: 2 TB pooled storage per user, Meet calls for up to 150 people |
| Upper | Business Premium: adds phishing and ransomware protection and controls on access to sensitive information | Business Plus: 5 TB pooled storage per user, Meet calls for up to 500 people |
Plan details come from Microsoft's business plan overview and Google Workspace's pricing page, which also notes that its Business plans top out at 300 users. In our experience the subscription difference between comparable tiers rarely drives the decision. Where cost differences become meaningful is in migration and transition: switching platforms costs real time and money, and that cost often outweighs a year or two of subscription differences.
Where Microsoft 365 Has a Clear Edge
Microsoft 365 is the stronger choice in several scenarios that are common among Chicago-area SMBs.
If your business depends on complex Excel spreadsheets (financial models, operational data analysis, pivot tables, advanced formulas), Microsoft Excel is meaningfully more powerful than Google Sheets. This matters most for professional services firms, financial advisors, operations-heavy businesses, and anyone whose core workflows live in spreadsheets that go beyond basic data entry and reporting.
If your team produces documents that need precise formatting (contracts, proposals, reports with complex headers and footers, documents that clients and partners will print), Word gives you more control than Google Docs. Google Docs has improved substantially, but the rendering differences between platforms and the formatting inconsistencies when converting between file types are real issues for document-intensive businesses.
If you're in a regulated industry (healthcare, financial services, legal, government contracting), Microsoft 365's compliance and security toolset is more mature. Features like eDiscovery, data loss prevention, Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure Active Directory) and Microsoft Purview were built for regulated environments. Google Workspace has added compliance features, but Microsoft has a longer track record and more depth here. Whichever you pick, our cybersecurity checklist for small businesses covers the settings to turn on first.
If your team is already on Windows and familiar with the Office suite, the friction of switching is real. People know where things are. Existing macros, templates, and custom formatting work. The learning curve for your IT administrator is lower. When the incumbent platform serves the business well, there's often no compelling reason to switch.
Where Google Workspace Has a Clear Edge
Google Workspace wins in its own set of scenarios that are equally common among the businesses we work with.
If real-time collaboration is central to how your team works (multiple people writing and editing documents at once, commenting and resolving feedback in context, working from different devices without worrying about which version is current), Google Workspace is better. Its collaboration model is native rather than added on. Microsoft has made significant improvements to real-time co-editing in recent years, but Google still has the smoother experience for teams that spend their day collaborating on documents.
If you're a younger business without legacy Microsoft file dependencies, Google Workspace is easier to set up and administer. The admin console is straightforward, user management is intuitive, and you don't need an IT specialist to add users, reset passwords, or manage basic configuration. For a 10-person team where nobody has a dedicated IT background, that operational simplicity has real value.
If your team is distributed or remote, Google Workspace tends to feel more cohesive as a browser-based platform. Everything works regardless of operating system (Windows, Mac, Chromebook, Linux) without desktop software installation or licensing concerns. This matters for businesses with employees on different devices or contractors who need access without IT provisioning a machine.
If you're integrating with a lot of modern SaaS tools, both platforms have extensive integrations, and some newer SaaS products build their Google integration first. It isn't decisive, but it counts if your business runs on a stack of cloud tools.
The Migration Question
Switching platforms is the part of this decision that most businesses underestimate. Email migration is the easy part: moving mailboxes from one platform to another is well-documented and tool-supported. For a 20-person business, an experienced IT team can often complete the email cutover over a weekend. Microsoft's Google Workspace migration moves mail, calendars and contacts in batches, and Google's data import tool handles the reverse move from Exchange Online, OneDrive and SharePoint.
The harder part is everything else. Documents stored in Google Drive don't convert cleanly to Microsoft format, and vice versa. Formatting drifts. Formulas behave differently. Any macros or scripts written in Google Apps Script don't work in Microsoft 365, and VBA macros don't work in Google Sheets. If your team has built workflows, templates, or automations on one platform, those need to be rebuilt on the other, and that work is often invisible until someone tries to do it. Even Microsoft's own Migration Manager for Google Drive notes that file-level permissions and older file versions need explicit settings to come across.
Calendar integrations with third-party tools, CRM connections, scheduling software, and any apps that are tightly coupled to one platform need to be re-evaluated. Some will work with both; others are built around one ecosystem and will require alternative tools or custom integration work.
For a small business with 10 to 50 employees making a full platform switch, realistic planning should account for two to four weeks of transition time, including a parallel running period, user training, and a tail of resolving edge cases after cutover. Factor this into the decision honestly, because a migration that's poorly planned is one of the fastest ways to disrupt a team's productivity at exactly the wrong moment.
A Framework for Making the Call
Three questions most reliably point to the right answer for the businesses we work with in the Chicago area.
What does your team use most? If your employees spend most of their day in Word, Excel, and Outlook and know the keyboard shortcuts by heart, switching to Google Workspace creates friction that shows up in lost productivity for months. If your team already lives in a browser and treats email as just one of many communication tools, Google Workspace feels natural and Microsoft 365 will feel clunky. Respect where your team is already comfortable.
What's your most complex document or spreadsheet workflow? Pull up the three most important documents or spreadsheets in your business, the ones you couldn't function without. Open them in the other platform and see what breaks. This is the fastest way to discover whether a migration is straightforward or a significant project. If everything looks fine, the switch is lower-risk. If formulas break, formatting shifts, or macros stop working, you have a clear signal of what migration effort looks like in practice.
Where is your IT complexity headed? A 15-person consulting firm with straightforward workflows and modern tooling is a very different environment from a 60-person logistics company with compliance requirements, custom software integrations, and a mixed Windows/Mac environment. The simpler the IT environment, the more Google Workspace's operational simplicity matters. As complexity grows, Microsoft 365's broader enterprise feature set starts to justify the added administrative overhead. If AI assistants are part of the plan, our comparison of ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini and Claude covers how each fits its suite.
The Decision Most Businesses Avoid
What we see most often is a business that has drifted into a mix of both platforms without ever deciding. Some employees use Outlook, some use Gmail. Files live in both Drive and OneDrive. Documents get converted back and forth and gradually accumulate formatting issues. No one is quite sure where the authoritative version of a file lives.
This is especially common among businesses that grew quickly without standardizing early. The cost isn't visible on any invoice, but it's real: time wasted on file versioning confusion, collaboration friction between teams on different platforms, and the overhead of administering two environments instead of one.
If that describes your business, the decision to make is how to get everyone onto one platform and keep them there. That's a project worth planning properly, with the right support, rather than something to tackle over a few weekends; it belongs on your IT roadmap.
We assess businesses across the Chicago area on which platform fits their current environment and what a migration would involve. Get in touch and we'll give you a straight answer.